The relevant theorems are:
and string u,
M can determine whether
accepts u.
such that
no TM M can determine, given an input string u, whether
accepts w.
Note that these two theorem are not interderivable. In the ``Florida story" involving Welty and Shapiro, I idiotically tried to get the second of these from the first --- and then realized that was impossible, something I should have remembered from elementary computability theory (see below)!